The Night Hunt
I had recently gotten into fly fishing, a family of brothers that I grew close to in high school invited me to take part in a steelhead fishing trip on the Pere Marquette river. We fished five fishless days, something that I will never forget, and for reasons unexplainable I was very attached to. It could have been I had never been on a drift boat, or a river so clear and gorgeous, or that I couldn’t wrap my head around what fish of such size were doing in such a place?
Whatever it was, this was my inauguration into fly-fishing. I ditched the idea of any other type of fishing, enthralled by the constant flow of the river and confused by the nature of the fish we were pursuing. For days after this trip I laid in bed seeing the passing river, with darting steelhead through my mind like counting sheep. Although our trip had the misfortune of a few break offs and no pictures with a silver trophy, I was lured into the promise of the upcoming season. Talk of streamer fishing, mayfly hatches, and even some spooky night fishing with flies that imitate mice, all of which was far over my head, but I couldn’t wait to try it.
A few months later, I found myself accompanying the same group of brothers and their father to the South Branch of the Au Sable River. Arriving at their house I was shocked to find nothing was ready. It must have been 5pm, as we gathered supplies to camp while waiting on the oldest of the three brothers to get home so we could depart on our two and a half our trip. I was told to relax, we are night fishing, and we will get there, set up camp, and still have plenty of time to fish. I had no clue of what they are talking about, I wasn’t exactly good at fly-fishing, and now they expect me to do so in the dark? They told stories of large trout enticed to the surface on a skated fly representing a small mammal. Again, all seem to belittle my understanding of what I considered fishing.
With camp set up in the dark we drive a bit up the Mason Tract, a place completely new to me, and for the first time seeing the canopied two-track my mind began to question the sanity of my friends. Just like the first time getting into their drift boat, I was along for the ride. We strung up our rods in the dimness of the backdoor light on their SUV. The moment was seized by my buddy’s father, who proceeded to hand out wooden tipped cigarillos, which previously appeared as celebratory stogies on a walleye fishing. The irony behind the gas station cigars, mixed with his quirky enthusiasm, turned into tradition, and eventually friendship folklore.
Making our way up the trail from where we parked, we all followed the older brother, as he seemed to know where we were going among the darkness. I carried with me a brand new Redington 5wt combo set I purchased prior to the trip with Hay bailing money. A single mouse tied to the end of a 3-foot leader of very strong tippet, and a hand sized trout net the same family got me for graduating high school. We gathered along side a cedar tree on a shallow bank. I continued my doubt, questioning the rivers depth, speed, and how the hell to fish this set up. “It’s never more than waste deep, there is big brown trout and all you have to do is just plop that fly on the water and let in sort of dance its way down stream.” Okay? I thought as the older brother stepped into the river. We were going to let him wade down a bit before sending the guy behind him. Like a crowded first hole on a golf course we sat waiting, eventually it was just me and the father and he continued to tell me this is the best way to catch big brown trout. I think all of them could sense my doubt and caution for such a sport. It was my turn to enter the river; the two of us lit a wood tipped cigarillo for good luck.
I made my way downstream. The glare from the night sky etched out my two friends further down stream of me. Across the river was a wall of cedar and pines that I thought if I stared long enough into a witch, or some sort of ghost would lure me to whatever is in the dark forest, the last thing I was focused on was fishing. Not ten minutes into my wade I hear from just up river. “Hey Brian you got that net?” I look behind me only to see a faint red dot making its way around the bend towards me. I chuckled as I put my cigar out seconds after leaving the rivers edge. I hollered back with the promise to net whatever he has on his line. The glowing pale fly line is darting it way down river, and is now parallel with me. Knowing that is its either zero or hero for me at this point I reach for the net and scoop towards my feet all in one motion.
As we make our way to the bank, we keep our headlamps off, even as I notice the fish’s tail folded over the side of my net. Suddenly the doubt and spook was gone, I became a believer as I turned on my headlamp on to see what was the biggest trout I had ever seen. As we took pictures of him holding up his trophy the half lit cigar hung form the side of his mouth, further tying reality to myth. That picture has escaped our possession. Lost somewhere in cyberspace, but forever burned in my memory. Knowing what I know today, that fish had to be every bit of two feet long, give or take an inch or two for ego purposes. Two years later I would become a believer once again.
Driving up US 131, with my girlfriend of the time in the passenger seat I had her convinced to venture to the South Branch so we could camp and I could attempted to mend my passion into her life. In my mind I pictured some brief time spent fishing, a fireside dinner, and me off into the night to throw mice. I’m sure in her mind she was caught between, why the hell am I doing this? And I guess whatever makes him happy? Regardless I made the turn in Kalkaska and we were headed east.
I spent over an hour hiking back and forth from the truck to our campsite along the river. We spent an hour or so upstream of camp casting at finger sized brook trout. Something some people take very serious, and I save for kids and girlfriends. After the boredom hit both us, I offered to head back to start a fire and think about dinner. We had the perfect campsite, there was an open yard mowed out leading down to the river. We had just finished dinner as the sun was setting, and a group of anglers made their way down the hill towards the river.
A father and his two sons, one of which joined the dad along the downstream trail. What seemed to be the younger of the two sat down on the bank a cast length away from our fire and proceeded to wait. Once it got somewhat dark he would wade out. Spend a few minutes casting, then turn on his headlamp and return to the bank to sit. All the time I grew frustrated as he was ruining my riverside romance. I chuckled to my girlfriend, alluding to the fact that he must have no clue what he is doing and that’s why his dad and brother left him at this bank. I had thought he would get in and wade downstream, so after an hour or so of watching him switch back and forth between wading out a few feet and flashing his headlamp I walked over to talk to him.
“Yeah we are from Cleveland, and last year I caught a giant brown right here.” I wished him good luck, and thought of him as an innocent fool to think that fish would appear again. Soon after my chat with the kid two headlamps made their way back up the trail. Their flashing head lights blinded the two of us sitting fireside, Explaining that downstream was a bust, and they are heading back to camp with a weekend of fishing ahead of them. I smiled as their lights disappeared, reached into the bottom of the cooler and pulled out a few beers. I looked over and told her to enjoy that and then its time to wader up. No more than fifteen or twenty minutes passed since the family of anglers left, and excited to get out and throw some mice I walked over to the same bank the kid was sitting on. Just a few warm up cast I thought, as I was in flip-flops and pajama pants.
Standing on the bank I cast out into the middle of the river. Seconds after, my fly was met by a loud smack of a swirl. I lifted and cast back ten feet above the swirl with lightning speed, knowing the fish missed the fly. A second swirl, one that could be described as the noise a clogged toilet makes when finally flushing down. In disbelief that I just hooked into a fish, I was reminded of reality by the pull and force of the fish. I screamed up to my girlfriend to bring me the net! As the fish is racing back up stream I am took off my pajama pants with the thought that I will have to jump in after this beast. As she arrives with the net, confused why I am in my underwear fighting this fish, it begins to make it way into my efforts.
Turning on my headlamp to net the fish alongside the bank I am taken back by its size. I yelled at her to run up and grab the cooler. Seeming how it has a tape measure of twenty inches on its lid. I pulled the fish out and laid it gently along the top of the cooler. Its long hooked jaw pushed out a few inches passed the edge. It must have been around midnight when I let that fish swim off, laughing and jumping with joy in disbelief of what just happened. “Should I still put on my waders?” She asked, absolutely not, I replied.
Was it the same fish that kid from Cleveland had caught last summer? Was it simply coincidence? Luck? Pay out for hiking all the gear down to the river? Regardless I was never so ready to explain to my friends how I had championed night fishing and spent the rest of the weekend pretending to like wine at her family’s lake house.
Years later I found myself fishing a different river with a new friend, an entire summer had passed and Dakota and I were well on our way to figuring out trout fishing in Northern Michigan. I had just returned from Cape Breton Island, and the late summer air was hot and humid. Hatch season was long over and fishing during the day meant small flies and sun burns. Dakota had mentioned doing some exploring to a new piece of water either of us had fished. The plan was to arrive at dusk so we could see what we would be fishing in, and then proceed to spend the night throwing mouse flies.
As we hiked around the sunset was engulfed by thunderstorm in the distance to the south. Flashes of lightning made their way just over the trees as we talked around about heading home. Seeming how we didn’t have cell signal to check to see if this storm was going to miss us or not. All was kept at bay by the northern sky being lit with stars, so we began to fish. Standing alongside side the banks of this stream I joked with Dakota about slowly stripping the mouse back up the near bank. A stupid tactic, as its assumed mice are not strong enough to swim upstream. But it wasn’t before I finished mentioning that, the sound of a bowling ball being dropped into the river drew my attention to the end of my rod. The line went tight and the rod bent in half, Dakota claims I let out a noise like I was either having sex or blew out a knee as the fish pulled its way upstream. Out of the corner of my eye, as I am trying to wrangle this fish I see Dakota cannon ball into the river, net in hand. The fish is upstream and bulldogging me hard on the bottom. I yell, “What in the fuck are you doing!” In my mind I was picturing all the steelhead I have seen lost at the net while fishermen get tangled at the feet by the escaping fish. As I am yelling I feel the fish begin to turn and make its way back down river.
I was sure at this point my dreams of a trophy are gone, the line is going to wrap around Dakota, the fish will shake off, and our other fishing buddies are going to laugh us out of the bar. But Dakota is a wild child, and the same disregard for normality that led him into the river led him to what appeared to be a nosedive towards the fish. In my head this felt like minutes, but it couldn’t have been more than 30 seconds and Dakota plops the net on the bank with a fish flopping around in it. I turn on my light to see the largest trout I had ever seen. I am so excited I reach over the net to grab Dakota and hug him like he just through the game wining touchdown pass.
“Hurry take a picture!” “Ah dude, I cant my phone is soaking wet.” I felt on top of the world as we watched that fish swim off. I begin to break my rod in half to hike out. Dakota was confused as he thought we were going to fish all night. And I explained there is no sense in trying to top that. This was truly a moment of bliss and luck below those stars and distant flashes of thunder and lightning.
Since that night I haven’t much fished the dark besides hatch season. In-between those three stories are a lot of fish and fishless spooky nights. Trying like hell to figure it out. Be it a size-less half lit cigar fish, a mystery pajama fish, or being caught off guard by the biggest fish of my life. I respect the night hunt, I love the night hunt, but I’ll never tame the night hunt.